The Dark Knight’s alter ego has been framed for murder before, but this time it is his best friend, Superman a.k.a. Clark Kent, who has been accused and arrested for murder. Batman’s latest case begins in Detective Comics #1115, “Clark Kent: Murderer, Part One,” brought to us by writer Tom Taylor and Mikel Janin, who provides the art, colors and standard cover. This is already shaping up to be a great story arc and a strong callback to a previous situation involving Batman, Superman and their alter egos.

Back in 2002, following the “Bruce Wayne: Murderer” storyline, Bruce Wayne: Fugitive found Batman deciding his Bruce Wayne identity was no longer necessary and not even bothering to clear his name. Superman swooped into Batman: Gotham Knights #27, “Murderer? Positive I.D.” by writer Devin Grayson and artist Roger Robinson, to talk to his friend. Clark let Bruce know he did not have to prove his innocence because Superman already believed, without a doubt, that Bruce didn’t do it. Fast-forward to this story arc, and we are left wondering whether Bruce can say the same about Clark.

Before we join Batman’s investigation, let’s check out these cool covers. Janin’s standard cover is classic crime noir, with the words “Clark Kent: Murderer: Part One” across a blood-stained floor. A handcuffed Clark is flanked by Deputy Jamie on his right and Larry, his former high-school football teammate who is now sheriff, on his left. Batman’s enormous shadow looms over all three against a white background, casting them in a sky-blue hue. A hint of red beneath Clark’s partially opened shirt reminds us that the man being led away in handcuffs is Superman.

Batman is in full detective mode on Claudio Castellini’s variant cover. Bruce sits in the Batcave, deep in thought at the Batcomputer as a colony of bats flies overhead among the cave’s stalactites. He looks ready for action, still wearing his cowl with the Batmobile illuminated nearby and ready to launch.

Dan Mora’s Watchmen 40th Anniversary variant is a work of art, showcasing Dr. Manhattan, The Comedian, Ozymandias, Nite Owl, Silk Spectre II and Rorschach. Mora captures the power and lasting impact of the original series so well that I can almost hear the question: “Who watches the Watchmen?”

There is also a variant cover by JG Jones available.

Like any good murder mystery, this issue begins with a murder in one of the most unlikely places. Days later, we catch up with the Man of Steel being a super role model to some of Metropolis’ youngest citizens. While Superman and the kids are enjoying their time together, news breaks about the murder—and the suspect is none other than Daily Planet reporter Clark Kent. The fluidity of these scenes is captured masterfully through Janin’s artwork and colors and Taylor’s writing. The mystery deepens as Clark flies home and prepares to face the accusation. He barely says anything to Lois, who is already in full defense mode. Batman, acting as both detective and concerned friend, attempts to contact Clark, but Clark figures they can talk later.

Clark remains cool, calm and collected even when confronted by Jamie, a nervous deputy who appears more than a little trigger-happy. Then again, as Larry points out, discovering murder victims might have something to do with Jamie’s behavior. Taylor and Janin do a terrific job launching this story arc while showing Superman’s family and friends steadfast in their trust in him as a good man, superhero and certainly no murderer. Members of the Justice League are ready to help clear Clark’s name because they believe the sheriff’s office has the wrong suspect. Batman, however, simply tells them that he is investigating.

The creative team also shows us how similar Bruce and Clark can be. Both men believe in keeping the people around them calm. They quietly and carefully maneuver through the issue in different ways: Batman follows the evidence wherever it leads, while Clark places his trust in the justice system and remains concerned about the people affected by the crime. That contrast makes the final exchange between the World’s Finest especially effective.

(10/10) After my fifth read-through of Detective Comics #1115, thinking about where the murder takes place and the heroes involved, I feel like we are getting the comic-book version of Lanterns—which was SOOOOOO GOOD!—and I am totally here for it. There are a few similarities right out of the gate, and I’m already looking forward to where this arc takes us. Is Clark Kent a murderer? Does Batman think he is? If Clark isn’t responsible, who is, and why was he framed? Most importantly, how will Batman and Clark clear his name?

Leave a Reply